• » Technical Articles
  • » Rapid sensory profiling methods for wine : workflow optimisation for research and industry applications
  • How to better manage your wine shelf-life
    Three free webinars in collaboration with Vinventions
    Infowine in partnership with Vinventions invites you to a series of 3 webinars focused on the key parameters you need to monitor at different winemaking stages to optimize wine profile and its long...
    Published on: 10/18/2021

Rapid sensory profiling methods for wine : workflow optimisation for research and industry applications

Brand, Jeanne - Thesis (PhDAgric)--Stellenbosch University, 2019

Rapid sensory profiling methods for wine : workflow optimisation for research and industry applications

Descriptive sensory analysis techniques are widely used and trusted methodologies. Due to time and cost constraints, the demand for cost-effective methods for profiling is growing rapidly in food and beverage industries including the wine industry. A number of rapid methods have been tested and validated for various food products. However, further work is needed to identify and address limitations of specific rapid methods, especially reference-based methods, when evaluating complex matrices such as wine. The majority of studies employed novice consumers or trained consumers as judges.

The wine industry has an advantage over most food industries with: (1) product experts who can serve as judges and (2) having an extensive lexicon in the form of aroma wheels available that can be used as check-all-that-apply (CATA) questions.

The objective of this study was to identify cost-effective, rapid sensory methods that can be used for wine profiling by researchers and the wine industry alike. Furthermore, the study aimed to optimise the identified methods and to propose workflows that include sensory methods and statistical procedures suited for wine sensory analysis applications.

Four rapid methods were compared to descriptive analysis (DA). The methods tested were CATA, rate-all-that-apply (RATA), Napping, and sorting. Results obtained for the rapid sensory method and DA were similar.

It can therefore be concluded that rapid methods are suitable for the sensory evaluation of wine. Industry professionals can therefore be used as sensory judges, and can use a pre-determined lists of attributes as verbalisation tools.

CATA and sorting provided the highest quality profiles with the best discrimination between products. Sorting highlights similarities and differences whereas CATA provides more detailed descriptions. In addition, these two methods were found to be easier than rate-all-that-apply (RATA) and Napping to use. Pivot profile (PP), a reference-based method, was validated against a CATA variant, namely frequency of attribute citation (FC).

It was concluded that PP should be used with caution because the choice of pivot on the sensory space could have an influence. This method could, however, be useful when direct comparisons between samples are required, such as benchmarking.

In addition to sensory method development, a number of statistical procedures were also proposed to assist with the interpretation of rapid method data. A workflow to calculate drivers of quality and a strategy to calculate confidence ellipses for PP data were developed. This study highlights the importance of selecting a fit-for-purpose method. The objective of the experiment being conducted, along with practical restrictions should be taken into account when deciding which method to use.

Thesis published by Stellenbosch University and available online via SUNScholar 

Published on 01/14/2020
Related sheets
© All Right Reserved
ISSN 1826-1590 VAT: IT01286830334
powered by Infonet Srl Piacenza
Privacy Policy
This website and its related third-party services make use of cookies necessary for the purposes described in the cookie policy. If you want to learn more about cookies or how to disable them (either totally or partially), please see the cookie policy. By closing this banner, scrolling through this page, clicking on a link or continuing navigation in any other way, you consent to the use of cookies.
More informationOK

- A +
ExecTime : 1,796875